Season Recap: Who was the Texas Stars MVP?

As the season is now clearly in the rear view, I wanted to take a little bit of time and recap some of the awards we've done here over the past few seasons, starting with who the Stars MVP was this season. I'll present the case for the top contenders and let you all fight it out in the comments, on Twitter and on Facebook.

Colton Sceviour
(Credit: Ron Byrd)

I've previously laid out the case that this was a career year for Colton Sceviour. His numbers speak for themselves. Playing in all but one of the Stars' games this season, Sceviour potted career highs in goals (21), assists (32) and points (53). He was one of the better players on the team at minus-8 and was constantly slotted on the top line, playing against the best the West had to offer this season (which was a lot).

Most remarkable among those stats was the impact of the tallies. His six game-winning goals amounted for almost 20% of the wins Texas got on the year period. He's money in the shootout, going 2/4 on the season, and scored on a penalty shot as well in the year.

Sceviour has become a true all-situations type player, something every player projected as an NHL third-liner should strive for. Additionally impressive to me this season was Sceviour's role as a veteran. We've previously discussed his role in bringing along the development of Scott Glennie while teamed up with Francis Wathier. It also struck me that Sceviour was mentioned by several of the ATO forwards as a vet player who helped them adjust to the pro game at the end of the season.

Matt Fraser
The Stars sort of used this picture everywhere, and why not? It's awesome. It was the photographer's computer background for most of the season. (Credit: Portraits by Deena)

How could you have an MVP conversation without including the team's leading goal scorer who also finished number two in league scoring as a rookie? That would be the bulk of the case for first-year man Matt Fraser.

Fraser has had quite the last 12 months. The undrafted forward led his WHL club, Kootenay, to the WHL championship and played in the Memorial Cup last May. After the season, he was signed to an entry level contract with the Dallas Stars and spent his first professional season scoring at will in Austin and elsewhere across the Western Conference. Fraser was named to the AHL's All-Star squad and was only beaten out for the goal scoring title on the final day of the regular season. (Cory Conacher notched a hat trick to make it to 39 overall.)

The obvious mark against him in this regard is defensive play. That was a problem for the entire Stars squad this season. The rookie did make huge strides in the back half of the season. At the end of December, he was at minus-11 but finished the season at minus-13 and even had a plus-6 month of March.

Fraser notched five game-winning goals and had eleven PPGs on the season. Fraser cooled off in 2012 on that mark though, as he only collected three PPGs from January on.

I think Fraser had a monster year and definitely a good one to build on. I don't think he's the MVP for this team this season, but he is definitely a nominee worthy of consideration.

Francis Wathier
(Credit: Portraits by Deena)

A constant competitor for his three years in Cedar Park, Francis Wathier deserves to be in the discussion for team MVP. Wathier set career highs in assists (24) and points (42). He only missed tying his career high goal mark of 19 by one. In a bad defensive year, Wathier was always strong on the backcheck, usually the first back to the zone among the three forwards, and finished with a team-best minus-4 (among players who were here all season).

Along with Sceviour, Wathier was a mentor for the younger players on the team. Glennie's physical tone had to have been picked up from Wathier, who seemed to know just when to go in for that big check and bring the fans and his team back into the game.

Wathier is another one of those every-situation players. He is always willing to go down to block a shot but was a workhorse for the Stars nonetheless, missing only one game this season. Additionally, he collected seven power play goals this season, second only to Fraser on the team.

Who do you think is the winner? Did I miss someone? Let's talk in the comments.


  1. Scevior probably presents the best case, but I'm voting with my heart for Wathier. Have loved how this guy plays for the past three seasons, and to see him not let up one bit in what became a dog of a season was inspiring. If I had to point to one guy on the roster and say, "I want the Texas Stars' personality to be *that*", I would point to Wathier. In Texas, we appreciate true grit.

    --Chris M.

  2. Francis (Frank the Tank) Wathier. The leader among top 6 forwards in most aspects and probably the only player with a plus rating through most of the season. I think you summed it up here in a previous post... eternal hustle

  3. Another vote for Watts. He is the heart and soul of this team--and has been since their arrival. A true hockey player's player, Wathier deserves recognition for his dedication to the forecheck, standing up for teammates, and leadership. I'd hate to see him go, as he is also genuinely one of the good guys. #38 all the way.

  4. Wow, some great cases for all three. Seeing Colton's stats like that, especially the ~20% of game winners stat, is definitely impressive. Didn't he also have a pretty slow start to the season? I seem to remember him being blanked until a few weeks in.

    I would have to vote Colton, Wathier, Fraser (rookie or not, he's a beast) based on your arguments here. Wathier gets bonus points for his constant hustle and great checks, for sure. Great write up!

  5. Gotta go with Frank.

    Stats, Leadership, and Dedication are my reasons why. Also, if you could put 5 of each guy out there at the same time, how would the team have faired??

    Side note: How many of the other players on the team would stay after a deflating loss and work out for an hour or so? I only know of one.

  6. Sceviour was the team's most consistent and most complete player. My vote is for #7.

    Not a word about Travis Morin? He should be a finalist in place of Fraser. Without Morin's slick passing, there is no Fraser mentioned as season MVP.
    -Ross B.

    1. I thought hard about including Morin. It's hard to not include him, but I think he needed to show more defensive responsibility to be included. Not buying into Coach Pyle's systems was also a rough part of his season, which is something that I don't think the MVP does.

  7. Francis Wathier is the most dedicated selfless player in the ahl. He goes 100% the whole time he plays. Defensively and offensively he delivers continous punishment to the opposing team with consistent clean hits/checks. His assist/goal record speaks for itself. He is also an inspiring role model/mentor for younger players/kids. Wathier does very well with the media/fans representing the Texas Stars thus completing the package that makes him the Most Valuable Player.

    R. Forehand


Post a Comment

Thanks for commenting. Remember to keep it civil. Using a name will help us identify replies and build a Texas Stars community.